Flycatchers


All photographs, no matter how poor, are copyrighted and may not be used without permission.
© 2006-2022 - All Rights Reserved



Vermilion Flycatcher

Vermilion Flycatcher




Here we will give an illustrated overview showing some of the flycatchers of the Utopia area and vicinity. We have used a large number of flycatcher photos in the weekly photo breaks over the last several years, as well as having many scattered about on other various pages around the site. Here we compile and sort all of them onto one page, plus add a dozen brand new photos, and provide some info about them. For those with interest we will briefly bore you with some fascinating flycatcher facts, and when you can't take it, just scroll through to the pictures.   :)

What good is a flycatcher? If you ever watched a Phoebe or Vermilion Flycatcher on a fenceline at a corral, you would want them nesting at your place. They are voracious fly eating machines. When nesting and feeding young in particular, their catch rate is incredible. I once watched and counted as a nesting Black Phoebe with four young, at a dumpster in California, caught 50+ flies in one hour. Very important hard work I do. As I recall that took a whole beer.

There is a great diversity of flycatcher species found around the Utopia area. Three are fairly well known by all. The Vermilion and Scissor-tailed Flycatchers are local favorties wherever they are. The other one everyone knows, but maybe not as a flycatcher, is Eastern Phoebe, which nests under eaves everywhere here. These three well show the variety in flycatchers here from small and incredibly colorful to flashy and fancy, and then sorta dull and plain, as many other flycatchers are.

Flycatchers do just that, and eat flying insects. Big types take wasps with ease. Eastern Phoebe is the only one to spend the winter here regularly in any numbers. In now my 20th year here, I have recorded 25 (!) species of flycatchers locally of which eleven (!) species breed or have bred. Then 14 are strictly migrants on passage going between breeding grounds northward and wintering grounds southward, where bugs.

A couple groups can be a bit tricky to ID, though if they were legally required to keep calling none would be. All have distinct vocalizations, and are often pretty noisy. Or at least call. Yet invariably when you find one you really need to call, it won't. It is a law of birding.

The main groups of flycatchers are Phoebes, Kingbirds, Pewees, two groups known by their genus names, Myiarchus and Empidonax, then plus a couple one-off unique types. We break them into these groups for discussion and comparison, showing 20 species here, so far. At the bottom of the page is the flycatcher section from the bird list page, slightly modified, with the area flycatcher list with status of all types found here.

~ ~ ~ ~ ~

The photos are overly cropped, and not max resolution. Some are just plain poor, most of those were taken with Mavica chisled onto floppy disk. The bearable ones were taken with a Canon Powershot SX40. We intend to find and add more better flycatcher photos to this page, this gets it going.

The Flycatchers of Utopia

PHOEBES

All three phoebes wag or dip their tails regularly. Generally, Eastern is the phoebe in east half of U.S., and the Black and Say's are western Phoebes.

This is an Eastern Phoebe. They are the common phoebe here nesting under your eaves if you are lucky. They are resident, present year round, though in winter the local birds are invaded by wintering individuals from northward fleeing cold.



These are a couple Eastern Phoebe fledglings just before
they left the nest later this same day, April 20, 2020.



Eastern Phoebe

Eastern Phoebe can show some yellowish tint below in fresh fall or winter plumage.



blackphoebe

This is a Black Phoebe. They are jet black above and snow white below with a sharp line of demarcation across the breast. The whole head and breast are all solid jet black, belly snow white. Not muddy like Eastern Phoebe. Several pairs were breeding locally 2003-2008, but when the big drought of 2008 set in they departed. There was a pair at the park pond spillway or 1050 bridge in town, a pair nested at Lost Maples, pairs at Concan and Garner, etc. We are just east of their range, they increase westward. This pic was on the Nueces River. I have only seen one locally in ten years now.



This is Say's Phoebe. Usually on a fenceline at edge of pasture, present only in winter (late fall to early spring). Note no streaking on underparts as female or imm. Vermilion Flycatcher, though Say's is mostly here when those are not.



MYIARCHUS (their genus)

These are a confusing group for many birders. Nothing did more to confuse them than the National Geographic Field Guide. They were not a problem until the 2nd edition horrible depictions became the reference. One cannot learn them from that plate. Great Crested Flycatcher is not brown-backed with a pot-belly. For pronunciation, try something like my-ARK-us. Proper emphasis on the ARK will make you sound authoritative. They have rufous in tail and wings, and yellow on underparts. Details of tail feathers will sort them out if they don't call, when easy to ID. Once learned well you will ID many of them by sight without call or details of tail feathers or mouth lining color. Once you really know them you will call 99% of them correctly instantly just looking at them. They are each unique in size, shape, and structure. When you check the details, they will match your initial gut response take virtually all the time, once you know them. A Brown-crested weighs 50 PERCENT more than an Ash-throated! Can you tell a 100 pound person from a 150 pounder? If so, then clearly it is just a matter of calibration to learn these. You are not likely acquire the knowledge and skills however if you are just focused on seeing the color of the mouth-lining.

Myiarchus are cavity nesters and will take a nest box, here especially Ash-throated is fond of them. Great Crested are fairly strictly along drainages where large leafy deciduous woodlands of more than an acre or two. Ash-throated are anywhere and everywhere here, often out in dry areas of junipers and live-oak grassland, and in yer Bluebird boxes. Brown-crested are along water in riparian only, and is irregular here. A few nest in good times for bugs, so not the last few years, but is a common breeder in brush-country just south.

This is the most common Myiarchus here, Ash-throated Flycatcher. They are widespread breeders throughout the area. Yellow on belly is very light and pale. Gray on breast is very light and pale, usually uneven, fading to ash-colored throat.



Great Crested Flycatcher showing the diagnostic pinkish-orange mouth-lining. Nice rictal bristles. The better to funnel those bugs right into that maw. These are very (kingbird) bright saturated yellow below with a sharp line of demarcation on breast to evenly medium gray upper breast to throat.



Great Crested Flycatcher showing the olive green back, which goes all the way to rump. Our other two Myiarchus, the Brown-crested and Ash-throated, both have brown backs.

Still have to find some Brown-crest pics.

KINGBIRDS (genus Tyrannus)

These are large robust flycatchers, often on powerlines or fencelines along road. The fan favorite Scissor-tailed Flycatcher is really a fancy-tailed Kingbird.
westernkingbird

Western Kingbird is the most common Kingbird here, though recently has been scarce in drought times with no flying bugs. Has nested locally, last few years only migrants seen. This one is in winter when accidental in Texas, in Sabinal, Jan. 27, 2019. The snow white outer webs on the outer tail feathers are diagnostic and usually obvious. Note yellow belly stops at lower breast, which is pale gray, as is back.



easternkingbird

Eastern Kingbird is black, gray and white, and pretty sharp despite its lack of color. Bright snow white tail tip is unique. They are scarce but regular here for a week or two in May on a fenceline if you get lucky. In fall they are less than annual but possible.



Eastern Kingbird

This one is in fall. You can see some old browner worn feathers (tertials) and some new fresh clean gray ones with crisp white edges, so an adult.



Eastern Kingbird

Eastern Kingbird has a diagnostic neat crisp snow white tail-tip.




<"couchskingbird"

This is a Couch's Kingbird. Note yellow extends high up breast to olive green on breast. Back is olive green as well. Often appears masked. Tail is notched (center). These nest commonly down in the brush country, especially near water as around Uvalde wet spots. They nested at very SW corner of Utopia in 2006. They have wintered here a few years as well, at park. Can occur in spring and fall rarely too. I would call it scarce and LTA - less than annual, but can occur any month. A pair was south of town for 6+ weeks in summer of 2022.



Couch's Kingbird

This is a docushot of a Couch's feeding one of 3 young fledged in Utopia on June 5, 2006. One of the further north known nestings and maybe the first ever for the species up on the Edwards Plateau - in the hill country.



Scissor-tailed Flycatcher

Scissor-tailed Flycatcher, male. Usually a common breeder, but can be scarce in drought times. Absent in winter from about Oct. 20 or so until March 20 or so. Male tail longer than female, and has more orange on underparts. Note tail feathers in crossed scissor-position. I presume holding them crossed keeps them from blowing about as easily in the wind.




Scissor-tailed Flycatcher

The black on the back is an artifact, caused by shade from the wing being held up and away from body (was hot), and a very low sun angle.



Scissor-tailed Flycatcher

This is an adult and a juvenile, which are yellow underneath with a shorter tail. Though adults molt their tails in late summer, so there are kingbird appearing short-tailed adults around in late summer (August).



Scissor-tailed Flycatcher

The adult female has a much shorter tail than the male, and less orange color below.



Scissor-tailed Flycatcher

This is a fresh adult male at maximum orange, and just starting to grow its tail back in after molting it. Late July to mid-August (here), short-tailed models are out there that can look sorta like Kingbirds.



Scissor-tailed Flycatcher

Here is a rear view of a fresh male Oct. 14, 2017. This is right before they depart for the season. Note black rump and uppertail coverts. The dark vs. light contrast really breaks the bird up well.



Vermilion Flycatcher

One of our flagship flycatchers... in a class by itself.
Vermilion Flycatcher

Vermilion Flycatcher, male. Females are paler brown above, with streaks on whitish breast and pale salmon belly and rearward.



They arrive in early March, and depart in September. This male wintered by the pond on the golf course adjacent to the Waresville Cemetery. Another local had a winter bird once as well, but they are accidental then.



Vermilion Flycatcher

This is a juvenile Vermilion Flycatcher. At first they are streaked on breast and a yellowish-salmon rearward below. Adult female similar but salmon colored rearward below. Note the streaked breast.



This is the wintering bird Jan. 26, 2020.



PEWEES (genus Contopus)

The two Wood-Pewee, and Olive-sided Flycatcher are Pewees. A movement so far though has failed to get Olive-sided renamed as Boreal Pewee. The Eastern Wood-Pewee is our only nesting type here. Western Wood-Pewee is a nearly accidental vagrant. I have seen a few, and only ID them when they make diagnostic calls. They look very similar. Olive-sided passes through in very low numbers more in spring than fall usually. Pewees sit very vertically, upright, and often return to the same perch they sallied forth from before they snagged that flying insect.

Eastern Wood-Pewee

This is an Eastern Wood-Pewee feeding young at Utopia Park. They only rarely nest there, but often seem to want to try. They need areas of big leafy deciduous trees to nest in. That is a Swift Setwing dragonfly that wasn't swift enough.



Eastern Wood-Pewee

This is a juvenile Eastern Wood-Pewee as indicated by crisp broad buffy wing bars. Grayish olive above, fairly dull and dingy looking overall.



Olive-sided Flycatcher has an 'open vest' look with very dark sides of the underparts and white running up the center. They also can show two white patches or tufts on lower back area from behind. It is a bigger more robust bird than the Wood-Pewee are. Often sits on the highest open snag sallying back and forth for bugs.



EMPIDONAX (their genus)

These have been called correctly, the bane of birdwatchers. To pronounce try em-PID-uh-nax. We only have one breeding species, but many types can occur as migrants. Generally they are olive to grayish olive above with two wingbars and an eyering, and often a breast band of olive or gray. Each has unique calls and songs, but many migrants silent.

empidonax

A generic Empidonax flycatcher. A quiz bird as I did not ID this one, so can't tell you what it was. It was Sept. 17 at Utopia Park. It popped out, I looked at it, decided to grabshot, the end. Never to be seen again, or heard. Isn't this fun? The pale underparts without much for a breast band suggest possibly an Acadian.



Acadian Flycatcher

Acadian Flycatcher, the only locally nesting Empidonax Flyctcher,



Acadian Flycatcher

Acadian Flycatcher appears less breast-banded than most other Empidonax, often appearing very pale of underparts.



leastflycatcher

This is a Least Flycatcher that was pigging out on termites as they emerged after a rain, occasionally foraging from ground. I had no idea you could fit that many termites in one of these. The most common migrant Empidonax here in spring and fall by factors.



Cordilleran Flycatcher

This is a bad pic of a good bird, so which is allowable. It was a long-distance accidently high ISO docushot grab. Canon autofocus grabbed the background on 9 of 10 shots. Miracle there is this one bad one. This is the Cordilleran Flycatcher at Utopia Park Oct. 14. It does not show how green above and yellowish below the bird was. Note the big white teardrop shape behind the eye typical of the two 'Western' Flycatcher complex species. Luckily it was giving diagnostic calls so I knew it was a Cordilleran Flycatcher I was looking for before I saw it.



Alder Flycatcher

This is an Alder Flycatcher. Sorry about the grainy and over-exposed, settings were for in the dark woods. It was much greener and yellower than these pics show. Fortunately it was in a calling mood unlike most that pass through. It makes a good generic Empidonax pic. Oliveish above, some yellowish below, usually a messy breastband of olive, two wingbars and an eyering. Ya seen one you seen 'em all, just hope they call.



Hammond's Flycatcher

Hammond's Flycatcher north of Utopia in Bandera Co., Dec. 25. 2005 Probably the first wintering documented on Edwards Plateau, and was the first Bandera Co. record. Note compact size and shape, gray head and throat contrast with green back, very short bill, long primary extension, etc.



Hammond's Flycatcher

Same Hammond's Flycatcher - Note yellow in lower belly, narrowness of bill, and broken eyering above with slight teardrop effect behind. Several years later I recorded one calling that spent two months of winter at Utopia Park. A few years ago one was found wintering at Lost Maples, so 3 local area records now, all in winter.



yellowbelliedflycatcher

This is much of a Yellow-bellied Flycatcher. These are slightly less than annual, you can easily miss them any given passage. Rare in late spring and fall. This and the two 'Western Flycatcher' types are the two most green above and yellow below types. The two 'Western Flycatcher' types are accidental vagrants out of range here (only Cordilleran recorded here).



Great Kiskadee

A unique very large robust tropical flycatcher. Uvalde County is a northerly stronghold for them as residents for decades now. Mostly around water in the Uvalde area, especially along Nueces River. They can dive in water for fish when cold and no bugs, or good fishin'.
Great Kiskadee

Great Kiskadee at Utopia Park Feb. 3, 2018. They breed at Ft. Inge, Cook's Slough, and the City Park on Hwy. 90 in Uvalde, all often have them. A few sight reports around Utopia, this one at the park in winter. Have a May record in the yard. It is a stunning beauty, and loud if they call, you can hear them from a half-mile or more.

Here is the flycatcher section from the Bird List page, modified slightly, showing status of each type found here. This assessment based on 20 years of local observation, knowing all the Empidonax by call.

25 species of flycatcher, 11 nest
Olive-sided Flycatcher - occasional spring and fall migrant.
Western Wood-Pewee - accidental thrice in spring, once in fall.
Eastern Wood-Pewee - common spring to late summer, breeds.
Yellow-bellied Flycatcher - rare in spring, very rare in fall.
Acadian Flycatcher - the nesting Empi in leafy woods along water, late April to August.
Alder Flycatcher - occasional to rare in spring, rarely ID'd in fall.
Willow Flycatcher - uncommon to occasional in spring and fall.
Least Flycatcher - uncommon in spring and fall, common on best days.
Hammond's Flycatcher - accidental in winter thrice: 2005-6 Cypress Hollow (ph.); 2010-11 at UP (audio); 2018-19 at LM (ebird).
Gray Flycatcher - accidental in fall (Bandera Co.); (+1 in E-bird July 25, 2007 at LM?).
     also saw a Gray at Ft. Inge in Uvalde in fall once.
Dusky Flycatcher - very rare to accidental in fall: Sept. 17, 2011 UP; one Thunder Creek Bandera Co. 2004, plus have seen two in Uvalde.
Cordilleran (Western) Flycatcher - Sept. 11, 2011 at library garden; ph. Oct. 14, 2020 at UP.
Black Phoebe - 2003-08 a few breeding pairs resident, since then (drought) very rare.
Eastern Phoebe - common resident, breeds, plus migrants invade for winter.
Say's Phoebe - uncommon to rare fall to winter.
Vermilion Flycatcher - nearly common spring to fall, breeds, very rare in winter.
Ash-throated Flycatcher - common early March to early August, widespread breeder .
Great Crested Flycatcher - uncommon spring to late summer, breeds in deciduous.
Brown-crested Flycatcher - scarce and local spring to summer, breeds rarely in riparian.
Couch's Kingbird - rare any season, has nested and wintered.
Cassin's Kingbird - rare spring migrant; ph. LM May 2007; pr. nr. Utopia April 26, 2014,
    a few more spring sightings since those, including pairs twice more.
Western Kingbird - formerly bred until drought, now scarce; spring to fall.
Eastern Kingbird - a few annually in spring, occasional to rare in fall.
Scissor-tailed Flycatcher - common spring to fall, breeds.
Great Kiskadee - two local sight reports surely good, plus: one S. of town May 8, 2016; one at UP (ph.) on Feb. 2-3, 2018.

abbreviations: UP - Utopia Park; LM - Lost Maples
~ ~ ~ ~ ~

THE END
Great Kiskadee

See ya!
scissortailedflycatcher





If you have arrived here from our Bird Photos page, you may close your browser to return to the Bird Photos index.

Other visitors may click your "Back" button on your browser or select a link to keep visiting!
All photographs within this site are copyrighted
and may not be used without permission.
All Rights Reserved.
© M. and K. Heindel 2023
www.utopianature.com